solo_knight: (Chomp)
[personal profile] solo_knight
First Impressions The Cog That Remains
(Find it in the current No ICE Bundle)


What is it?
A Wretched and Alone game, which means it’s a solo journalling game, played with a deck of cards and using a Jenga Tower mechanic (or paper substitute thereof), similar to Ice Station Zero (this is a whole genre; I've come across a fair few games by now).


Is it playable out of the box?
Looks like it. Bring your own knowledge of the topic.

Amendments:
I'm playing with the 'Ace of Hearts = Card 1' rule. A little wretched is one thing, hopeless is another.

Tools
1d6, a deck of playing cards, a tumbling (Jenga) tower or equivalent, ten tokens.

Price:
$9.99

Verdict
🧊 Put on Ice


It's not the game, it's me. It really is. I love the system – you get 52 (and here, 54) prompts which come up randomly; you have the additional Jenga tower mechanic (which I play with a paper equivalent since a physical tower would be less fair), but this type of game demands that you create your own story. Which is great.

But.

Firstly, I am strapped for time. I would like to try a second dedicated solo adventure this month. Then I'm poking at a Scarlet Heroes hexcrawl/wilderness adventure (and am learning a lot from that), and from time to time I poke at a freeform adventure (I have no system I play with or character stats; I'll add them when I need them, but so far, I'm just exploring).

Plus I'm downloading the _No ICE_ bundle (page 15 of 48; see link above) and despite a lot of games being duplicates, Windows-only, or for systems I have no interest in (eg Mothership) that's still A LOT of games to glance at and save.

This is a game about keeping a giant mecha running. I'd struggle coming up with appropriate stories about maintaining a car, but at least I've owned cars for many decades and done _some_ maintenance, and know what you use a car for.

I know nothing about giant mechas and their pilots, and after a week of staring at my first prompts and not coming up with anything useful, I have to conclude that this game needs more prep and more story brain than I am able to give it.

Which is a shame. Prompts like
Something about the Mecha’s original construction was flawed. Pull from the tower. What limb, part, or system simply doesn’t work the way it should? How do you jury-rig a solution?
sound like they will create great stories – there's just enough substance here to spark imagination and not enough to feel railroaded.

I, however, am in the 'wait, they have limbs? What kind of limbs' stage; I have no knowledge of my own to link this prompt to, and this game feels like work. Work that I am not willing to put in, not while other settings/stories sound so much more interesting.

So, with some reluctance, I am letting this go, or rather, putting it on ice in the hope that one day I may feel bored and curious enough to go back to it.
This account has disabled anonymous posting.
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

Profile

solo_knight: (Default)
solo_knight

March 2026

S M T W T F S
12 34567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Mar. 4th, 2026 08:45 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios